Did Prophets of Allah Commit any Sin?

Did Prophets of Allah Commit any Sin?

Doctrine of the Infallibility of the Prophets

We believe that all the prophets are infallible, and also that the 12 holy Imams [PBUTH ALL] (the progeny and successors to the Prophet of Islam (PBUH&HP) are infallible, but some non-Shi'a Muslims do not believe in the infallibility of the prophets, let alone of the Imams. Infallibility means purity from all sins, both major and minor ones', and from mistakes and forgetfulness. It is necessary that a prophet should not even do what is contrary to good manners: that is, he should not behave vulgarly, for example by eating in the street, by laughing aloud, or by doing anything which may be unacceptable to public opinion.

The reason for the necessity of the infallibility of a prophet is that if he commits a sin or mistake, or is forgetful or something similar, we have to choose between two alternatives: either we obey his sins and mistakes, in which case, in the view of Islam, we do wrong, or we must not obey his sins and mistakes, which too is wrong, because this is contrary to the idea of prophethood where obedience is necessary; besides, if everything he says or does has the possibility of being either right or wrong, then it is impossible for us to follow him. The result is that the benefit of his mission is lost; it becomes unnecessary, and the prophet becomes like ordinary people whose acts and speech do not have the excellent worth that we seek, with the result that there will be no obedience and his actions will be unreliable. The same reason is adduced for the infallibility of the Imams [PBUTH ALL], because we believe that the Imam is appointed by Allah as the Prophet's representative (Caliph) to guide mankind. This will be explained in the section on the Imamate.

Why are the Prophets free of sin and error?

Without doubt, more important than anything else, a prophet must attract the trust of the general public in such a way that his words contain no possibility of being lies or erroneous, otherwise, his position of leadership will be a shaky one. If they are not immaculate, using the excuse that the prophets have erred, people who seek the truth from what they say will begin to doubt their invitation. It will not be accepted, or, at least, their words will not be accepted with all of their hearts. This reason which can be called `trustworthiness' is one of the most important reasons for their being immaculate. In other words, how is it possible that God give His Commands for His people to follow a person who is not truthful for if this person were to err or sin, people would not follow him. If they do, they have erred and if they do not, they have weakened his position of leadership, in particular, since the position of the leadership of the prophets completely differs with the leadership of others for people receive their entire program of life from the prophets. Because of this, we see that the great commentators speak about the verse, " O you who have faith! Obey Allah and obey the Apostle and those vested with authority among you...".(1)

saying that the command for Absolute obedience is because the Prophet is immaculate as well as `being charged with authority'. The pure leaders like the Holy Prophet are referred to as `being charged with authority'. If not, God would never give the command to unconditional obedience to them. Another way of proving the immaculateness of the Holy Prophet in relation to any sin is that any factor of sin is condemned to defeat within the very being of the Holy Prophet. The explanation of this is: when we turn to ourselves, we see that we, too, are immaculate in relation to some sins or evil or unacceptable deeds. Note the following examples: Can you find an intelligent person who thinks about eating fire or trash or filth? Can you find an intelligent person who will walk naked through the streets and bazaars?

Clearly not, if we saw such deeds from someone, we will be assured of the fact that he is no longer normal and has become insane because an intelligent person would never do these things. When we analyze such behavior, we see that the ugliness of such deeds is so clear that an intelligent person would never even consider them. It is here that we can imagine what this short phrase means and say that every intelligent and healthy person is `free of unacceptable deeds. From this stage, we take a step further. We see some people who are free from unacceptable deeds. For instance, an aware physician and expert who knows the various kinds of microbes well is never prepared to drink the polluted water of the dirty clothes of a person who has one of the most dangerous contagious diseases whereas an illiterate person , perhaps, would be indifferent to such a thing. With another simple example, we reach the point that however much the level of a person rises in the area of awareness, they are less likely to do evil or ugly deeds. Taking into consideration that if a person's faith and awareness were to rise and have so much faith in God and His court of justice, so that everything that he sees is present before his eyes, such a person will be free of all sin and every ugly deed in relation to him, like walking naked through the streets, will be in our eyes only. For such a person, the property of soniething forbidden is just like the flames of fire, and just like we do not put fire in our mouths, he does not put something which is forbidden into his mouth. We can then conclude that the prophets, because of the extraordinary knowledge, awareness and faith which they have, tame the motives of sin and the most exciting factors causing sin will not prevail upon his intellect and faith. This is why we say that the prophets are immaculate; they are insured against sin.

Sources:

  1. Lessons about Allah, Prophet, Justice, Leadership (imamate), Resurrection - by Ayatullah Nasir Makarim Shirazi.
  2. The faith of Shi'a Islam - By: Muhammad Ridha Al-Muzaffar

reference:

(1) (4:59)